Faith, Fear, and Fascism: The Role of Religion in George Orwell's Nineteen Eighty-Four (1984)

This blog is written as a task assigned by the head of the Department of English (MKBU), Prof. and Dr. Dilip Barad Sir. Here is the link to the professor's blog for background reading: Click here.

Video - 1: "God is Power"
Video - 2: Critique of Religion
Additional Resources:
References

Video - 1: "God is Power"

Video on God is Power | 1984 | George Orwell on YouTube/DoE-MKBU: Click here.

1. Introduction

The exploration of the phrase "God is power" within George Orwell's 'Nineteen Eighty-Four' offers profound insights into the novel's intricate portrayal of totalitarianism, the subversion of religious concepts, and the manipulation of human consciousness. The video analysis delves deeply into these themes, providing a nuanced understanding that I found truly enlightening. This response reflects my admiration for the video's critical examination and the thought-provoking perspectives it presents.

2. The Subversion of Religious Concepts

One of the most compelling aspects of the analysis is its focus on how the Party in 'Nineteen Eighty-Four' appropriates and distorts religious concepts to consolidate its power. The video's observation that the word "God" appears approximately eight times in the novel underscores the deliberate and calculated use of religious terminology by the Party. This manipulation serves to replace traditional religious beliefs with an unwavering devotion to Big Brother, effectively positioning the Party as the ultimate deity. I found this truly insightful, as it highlights Orwell's critique of how totalitarian regimes can exploit religious sentiments to achieve absolute control.

3. The Party's Control Over Human Consciousness

The analysis delves into the Party's systematic efforts to erode individual thought and autonomy, transforming citizens into mere instruments of the state. The discussion on how the Party dictates emotions, compelling citizens to hate or love on command, is particularly striking. This concept really made me think about the extent to which authoritarian regimes can manipulate personal feelings to maintain their dominance. The video's examination of Winston's journey—from his belief in the "spirit of man" to his coerced acceptance of Party doctrines like "2 + 2 = 5" and "God is power"—vividly illustrates the devastating impact of such psychological manipulation.

4. The Party as the Ultimate Deity

The video's exploration of the Party's self-deification is profoundly thought-provoking. O'Brien's declaration,

"We are the priests of power,"

—signifies the Party's intention to supplant traditional religious structures with its own ideology, where power itself becomes the object of worship. This analysis sheds light on the Party's strategy to eradicate any allegiance that might compete with its authority, ensuring that devotion, obedience, and love are directed solely towards Big Brother. I found this perspective deeply insightful, as it emphasizes the dangers of political entities assuming the role of a deity, thereby eradicating personal freedoms and moral frameworks.

5. The Mechanisms of Totalitarian Control

The analysis provides a detailed examination of the mechanisms employed by the Party to maintain its totalitarian grip over Oceania. The discussion on the Party's slogan "Freedom is slavery" offers a profound insight into the use of paradoxical language to confuse and control the populace. By convincing citizens that individual freedom leads to downfall, the Party justifies its oppressive collectivism as a means to achieve true liberation. This concept really made me reflect on how language can be weaponized to distort reality and suppress dissent.

6. The Erosion of Individual Thought

The video's focus on the Party's assault on personal autonomy is both compelling and disturbing. The portrayal of citizens being conditioned to accept blatant falsehoods, such as "Two and two make five," illustrates the extent of the Party's control over reality itself. Winston's eventual submission, where he writes "God is power" after enduring torture, serves as a poignant example of the erasure of individual thought. This analysis underscores the terrifying effectiveness of psychological manipulation in enforcing conformity and loyalty to the Party.

7. The Dangers of Political Devotion

The analysis astutely highlights the perils of unwavering devotion to political entities. By transferring the concept of worship from a divine being to a political leader, the Party fosters an environment where questioning authority becomes tantamount to heresy. This blind allegiance paves the way for oppression and exploitation, as individuals are coerced into accepting the Party's version of truth without scrutiny. I found this perspective particularly enlightening, as it draws parallels to real-world scenarios where political cults of personality can lead to the erosion of democratic principles and individual rights.

8. Conclusion

The video's comprehensive analysis of the phrase "God is power" in 'Nineteen Eighty-Four' offers profound insights into Orwell's critique of totalitarianism, the subversion of religious concepts, and the manipulation of human consciousness. The exploration of these themes not only enhances our understanding of the novel but also serves as a cautionary reflection on the potential consequences of unchecked political power and the erosion of personal autonomy. This analysis has deepened my appreciation for Orwell's work and its enduring relevance in contemporary discussions about authority, freedom, and the human spirit.

Video - 2: Critique of Religion

Video on Critique of Religion | 1984 | George Orwell on YouTube/DoE-MKBU: Click here.

1. Introduction

The YouTube video's analysis of George Orwell's 'Nineteen Eighty-Four' as a critique of religion, particularly Catholicism, offers a compelling perspective that deepens our understanding of the novel's multifaceted themes. This interpretation sheds light on the intricate parallels between the totalitarian regime depicted in the novel and organized religious institutions. I found this analysis truly insightful, as it challenges conventional readings of the text and invites readers to consider the broader implications of Orwell's work.

2. Parallels Between Superstates and Abrahamic Religions

The video's proposition that the three superstates—Oceania, Eurasia, and Eastasia—mirror the three Abrahamic religions—Judaism, Christianity, and Islam—is a thought-provoking analogy. This concept really made me think about how these entities, both in the novel and in reality, exert control over their adherents and often engage in perpetual conflicts to maintain dominance. The idea that Orwell intentionally structured the superstates to reflect religious institutions adds a nuanced layer to the narrative, suggesting a critique of how religions can be manipulated to serve political ends.

3. Confession and Penance: A Reflection of Religious Practices

The analysis draws a compelling parallel between the forced confessions in 'Nineteen Eighty-Four' and the sacrament of confession in Catholicism. Winston's coerced admissions under torture resemble the act of penance, where individuals confess sins to attain absolution. This comparison highlights the manipulation of personal guilt and the exploitation of confession as a tool for control. I found this truly insightful, as it underscores Orwell's critique of how confession can be weaponized to suppress dissent and enforce conformity.

4. "We Are the Priests": The Party's Ecclesiastical Imagery

O'Brien's declaration,

"We are the priests of power,"

—equates the Party members to religious clergy, positioning the Party as a new form of priesthood. This ecclesiastical imagery suggests that the Party has assumed the role of a religious institution, demanding unwavering faith and obedience from its followers. This concept really made me think about the ways in which totalitarian regimes adopt religious symbolism to legitimize their authority and command devotion.

5. Big Brother as a Deity

The portrayal of Big Brother as a god-like figure, omnipresent and omniscient, mirrors traditional depictions of a deity. The slogan—

"Big Brother is watching you"

—serves as a constant reminder of the Party's surveillance, akin to the all-seeing eye of a god. This parallel emphasizes the replacement of religious faith with political ideology, where loyalty to Big Brother supplants spiritual devotion. I found this perspective deeply insightful, as it illustrates the Party's strategy of co-opting religious sentiments to fortify its control.

6. Structural Symbolism: The Pyramidal Hierarchy

The video's observation that the Party's pyramidal structure and the organization of its Ministries evoke the Christian Trinity offers a fascinating insight into the novel's symbolic architecture. This structural design reflects a hierarchy that demands absolute allegiance, mirroring the authoritative frameworks found in religious institutions. This concept really made me reflect on how organizational structures can be engineered to reinforce ideological dominance and suppress individual autonomy.

7. Regulation of Personal Relationships

The Party's stringent control over personal relationships, including the promotion of celibacy and regulated marriages, parallels doctrines found in various religious traditions. By dictating intimate aspects of life, the Party seeks to eliminate personal loyalties that might compete with devotion to Big Brother. I found this truly insightful, as it highlights the extent to which authoritarian entities will intrude into private spheres to maintain unchallenged authority.

8. Room 101 and Religious Imagery

The comparison of Room 101 to Dante's Inferno is a striking analogy that enriches the novel's thematic depth. The Ministry of Love's resemblance to a multi-layered hell, with O'Brien as a Lucifer-like figure, underscores the use of fear and suffering as instruments of control. This concept really made me think about how the appropriation of religious imagery serves to intensify the psychological manipulation exerted by the Party.

9. Orwell's Personal Critique of Religion

The video delves into Orwell's personal experiences and criticisms of organized religion, particularly Catholicism. His disillusionment with the Church's collaboration with fascist regimes during the Spanish Civil War and his broader skepticism towards religious institutions are reflected in his literary works. This context provides a deeper understanding of the anti-religious undertones in 'Nineteen Eighty-Four,' illustrating how Orwell's personal convictions informed his portrayal of the Party's oppressive mechanisms.

10. Religious Allegory in 'Animal Farm'

The analysis extends to Orwell's 'Animal Farm,' highlighting the character of Moses and the concept of Sugarcandy Mountain as allegories for religious figures and the promise of an afterlife. This inclusion demonstrates Orwell's consistent critique of how religion can be used to placate and control populations, diverting attention from present injustices with promises of future rewards. I found this truly insightful, as it showcases Orwell's nuanced understanding of the interplay between religion and power.

11. The Dangers of Power Worship

The video's emphasis on Orwell's warning against the worship of power, whether through religious or political institutions, resonates profoundly. The novel serves as a cautionary tale about the potential for any system of absolute authority to devolve into oppression and exploitation. This concept really made me reflect on the importance of maintaining a critical perspective towards all forms of concentrated power, ensuring that individual freedoms and ethical considerations are not sacrificed in the process.

12. Conclusion

The YouTube video's analysis of 'Nineteen Eighty-Four' as a critique of religion offers a multifaceted perspective that enriches our comprehension of Orwell's intentions. By drawing parallels between the Party's totalitarian regime and organized religious institutions, the analysis illuminates the intricate ways in which power can be consolidated and maintained through the manipulation of belief systems. This exploration has deepened my appreciation for Orwell's work, highlighting its enduring relevance in discussions about the intersections of politics, religion, and individual autonomy.

Additional Resources:

Click here to watch the full playlist on 1984 by George Orwell on YouTube\Course Hero.

Video on 1984 by George Orwell, Part 1 on YouTube/CrashCourse: Click here.

Video on 1984 by George Orwell, Part 2 on YouTube/CrashCourse: Click here.

Video on 1984 - Book Summary on YouTube/GradeSaver: Click here.

Video on Orwell's 1984 Summary on YouTube/VideoSparkNotes: Click here.

Video on Newspeak on YouTube/alawooz: Click here.

Video on George Orwell's 1984: Why it still matters on YouTube/BBC News: Click here.

Video on How to recognize a dystopia - Alex Gendler on YouTube/TED-Ed: Click here.

Video on What "Orwellian" really means - Noah Tavlin on YouTube/TED-Ed: Click here.

References

Barad, Dilip. “Critique of Religion | 1984 | George Orwell.” YouTube, uploaded by DoE-MKBU, 21 Feb. 2023, youtu.be/Zh41QghkCUA. Accessed 27 Feb. 2025.

---. “God is Power | 1984 | George Orwell.” YouTube, uploaded by DoE-MKBU, 21 Feb. 2023, youtu.be/cj29I_MU3cA. Accessed 27 Feb. 2025.

Faith, Fear, and Fascism: The Role of Religion in George Orwell's Nineteen Eighty-Four (1984)

Faith, Fear, and Fascism: The Role of Religion in George Orwell's Nineteen Eighty-Four (1984)

Video - 1: "God is Power"

1. Introduction

2. The Subversion of Religious Concepts

3. The Party's Control Over Human Consciousness

4. The Party as the Ultimate Deity

5. The Mechanisms of Totalitarian Control

6. The Erosion of Individual Thought

7. The Dangers of Political Devotion

8. Conclusion

Video - 2: Critique of Religion

1. Introduction

2. Parallels Between Superstates and Abrahamic Religions

3. Confession and Penance: A Reflection of Religious Practices

4. "We Are the Priests": The Party's Ecclesiastical Imagery

5. Big Brother as a Deity

6. Structural Symbolism: The Pyramidal Hierarchy

7. Regulation of Personal Relationships

8. Room 101 and Religious Imagery

9. Orwell's Personal Critique of Religion

10. Religious Allegory in 'Animal Farm'

11. The Dangers of Power Worship

12. Conclusion

Additional Resources:

References

Thank you!

You might like